GiftMusic Review: We Ordered a Custom Birthday Song and Had It Within the Hour

GiftMusic Review: We Ordered a Custom Birthday Song and Had It Within the Hour

We were optimistic about the standard personalized song flow (sequence), so we filled out a long form, waited a couple of days, and hoped that the song wouldn’t sound generic. We ended up with a seven-part quiz that didn’t take much time at all, a finalized custom-made pop song shortly after my order came through, and a set of lyrics that were useful for the cooking class, the sunflowers, and even the snack we were going to make for the beach trip that we had previously mentioned. The process was even repeated twice with rough and elaborate responses, respectively, both with real sounds of a singer over a real arrangement. We also checked external GiftMusic reviews that we found.

Our verdict: 4.8/5. GiftMusic does a great job of this: it takes a few memories and creates a song that is complete and tailored to the individual. It is an easy questionnaire, an unusually rapid delivery period from the website (24 hours as stated), and there is a song page ready to share. There’s nothing too bad about it; there’s little that we’d point out except that sometimes the lyrics are taken too literally, and you have to click through from the e-mail to the page listing the track we have to say. Neither got in the way of the gift.

Here are a couple of things to keep in mind in advance:

  • You can select from 14 styles of music and also from a male, female, or no preference voice.
  • You don’t compose a line of lyrics; you answer questions.
  • The standard delivery time is less than 24 hours, and under an hour if you order a rush. Our songs come to you within the blink of an eye.
  • The song appears on a private, shareable page that provides the full song text, a download link, and a redo request that allows you to request changes to the song.
  • We haven’t gone into pricing here, as the package will vary according to what you have (rush delivery, redos for unlimited, etc.).

What is GiftMusic?

GiftMusic makes one-off songs about a specific person, built from details you supply through a guided questionnaire. The site pitches it as “the gift that outlasts flowers,” making it a memorable addition to any birthday celebration. The events that it mentions encompass nearly every occasion for which you might consider having one: Birthdays, anniversaries, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, weddings, graduations, memorials, thank yous, apologies, and “just because. It includes virtually every reason you would have for having one: Birthdays, anniversaries, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, weddings, graduations, memorials, thank yous, apologies, and that old standby “just because.

The result is a finished song with voices (as a web page that you can share with a link) and complete lyrics (verse by verse). According to the homepage, it served more than 100,000 families and has got an average of 4.9 across Mgmt’s 13,000-plus reviews. Again, we can’t verify those, but what we got is in the ballpark with some of the comments mentioned on the site.

Here is one thing to note, though, and the terms outlined in the website’s song creation section are somewhat referenced with the terms “songwriters,” “the studio,” etc.: GiftMusic terms allow the creation of songs through automated systems, artificial intelligence, third-party technology, human review of the songs, or a combination of the above. This is definitely a lot of automation, as our songs came in pretty quickly. We’ll classify the results as professional and not hand-recorded, yet our cuts were perfectly sound and sounded just as they would if they had been recorded professionally with no copyright watermark, so much so that we wouldn’t have guessed one way or another, but read the fine print.

How GiftMusic works: a seven-step questionnaire

The whole order happens inside a seven-step flow at giftmusic.com/create, with a progress bar across the top so you always know how far along you are. The site estimates five minutes to create a new song; that’s about right if you know what you want to say, and closer to ten if you stop to think about memories.

The steps are approximately as follows: You first state the recipient of the song (father, friend, I myself, or other) and the purpose of the song. After that, you indicate the name of the person you’re sending the message to and the person you’re sending it from. The first step is the music; the fourth is the sound: 14 genres on one single screen (more on this below! After that is the vibe of the song and the type of voice; if you want a male voice, a female voice, or leave this song open to them. After you list your favorite memories about the person, that is the part of the lyrics which will do most of the work. The final questions are focused questions; this includes nicknames/phrases to include, particularly things to avoid, and their favourite things.

Every step has a Back button, and nothing is locked once you move on, so it’s easy to go back and add a memory you forgot. The final step just asks for your email address, with an optional phone number, and reminds you that the song will land there. The account creation and order confirmation come after the questions, not before, which means you can look through the whole flow without committing to anything.

The memory step is the one to spend time on. Our vague-answers run produced a pleasant but general song; the detailed run produced the one we’d actually give someone.

GiftMusic genres, voice options and delivery time

First of all, the downplaying of the homepage to “pop”, “acoustic” and “R&B” was a surprise since the entire genre menu is presented. These are country, acoustic, piano ballad, RNB, pop, gospel, rock, hip-hop, jazz, folk, lullaby, Latin, lo-fi, and synthwave. That’s a bigger spectrum than most custom-song offerings have, and it encompasses some handy exceptions: lullaby for a new child, gospel for a grandparent, synthwave or lo-fi for anyone who’d look at the ballad with eyes rolling. So we chose pop for our birthday song, and it came back bright and cheerful; appropriate for a birthday.

Vocal choice is a straightforward three-section: Male, Female, or no preference. You can’t check out any individual singer’s voice or hear samples before ordering, and the service does not guarantee you that it will match the voice you hear to a particular genre and mood. In our case, it did.

When placed for delivery, the site quotes most songs within 24 hours and provides a situation termed a rush that guarantees an initial version within an hour. You may select the “rush delivery” option or have an “unlimited redo option” at the order step. We didn’t want the rush, as it were, since both our normal orders took about 6 minutes. But rather than a certainty, let’s say this was a good day, and I’m assuming the 24-hour number was conservative.

Tracking your order

Once the order is in, you’re taken to a page called Your Song Journey, a six-stage tracker that runs from Setting Up the Studio through Reading Your Story, Writing the Lyrics, Recording the Song, Final Mix & Polish, and Song Delivered. It updates on its own without a refresh. 

The stage names are more theatre than literal process, but the page gives you something to look at, builds anticipation for the first play, and makes it obvious the order went through.

When the song is ready, you get an email saying so, with a link back to the site. The track isn’t attached to the email; you click through to the song page, which sits inside your account, and from there you can stream it or download the audio file to keep. It’s one extra click compared with a file in your inbox, but it means the song page, the lyrics, and the download all live in one place.

GiftMusic song quality: lyrics and audio

First of all, the downplaying of the home page to “pop”, “acoustic” and “R&B” was a surprise since the entire genre menu is presented. These are country, acoustic, piano ballad, RNB, pop, gospel, rock, hip-hop, jazz, folk, lullaby, Latin, lo-fi, and synthwave. That’s a bigger spectrum than most custom-song offerings have, and it encompasses some handy exceptions: lullaby for a new child, gospel for a grandparent, synthwave or lo-fi for anyone who’d look at the ballad with eyes rolling. So we chose pop for our birthday song, and it came back bright and cheerful; appropriate for a birthday.

Vocal choice is a straightforward three-section: Male, Female, or no preference. You can’t check out any individual singer’s voice or hear samples before ordering, and the service does not guarantee you that it will match the voice you hear to a particular genre and mood. In our case, it did.

When placed for delivery, the site quotes most songs within 24 hours and provides a situation termed a rush that guarantees an initial version within an hour. You may select the “rush delivery” option or have an “unlimited redo option” at the order step. We didn’t want the rush,h as it were, since both our normal orders took about 6 minutes. But rather than a certainty, let’s say this was a good day, and I’m assuming the 24-hour number was conservative.

The audio is clean and radio-worthy: solid front voice, complete instrumentation behind him, correct structure with intro, 2 verses, chorus, bridge, chorus, and the outro. Played on laptop speakers & headphones and heard nothing that sounded clipped or synthetic. The detailed brief was well worth the time, as the service can only perform what it is given.

Two observations from the intro that don’t draw condemnation or assign praise. Sometimes the lyrics take the intro literally, and the sender’s name is in the opening to the song, and the sunflowers return multiple times. An extra word now and again is a bit chatty for this kind of tune, things that a human editor might edit out. It’s not, of course, something one would notice at first listen, at a birthday dinner, and the redo feature allows you to request just such a trim.

Sharing the song and how it works on mobile.

There are three sharing buttons on the song page: Facebook, text message, and copy link. Besides, there’s a download feature that allows you to save the audio file and send it via any means, or play it at the party on your mobile phone without having to connect. The link is still the simplest option, as it will display the same Link/Player with lyrics for the recipient. It is possible to select and copy the lyrics as text as well, which is convenient to be able to print them on a card with the song.

You can edit the page title using the small pencil icon; this will allow you to change the name of the song before you share it. There is a 5-star prompt of “How did we do?” underneath the lyrics, as well as a Request a Redo button, and a limited offer to give the recipient a chance to upload a reaction video of them listening to the song from someone they had never heard before.

On a phone, everything held up. The questionnaire’s genre grid, the tracker, and the song page all reflow cleanly, making the custom gift easy to explore, while the player and share buttons are easy to hit with a thumb. Since the recipient is likely to open the link on their phone, that matters more than the desktop view.

Redos and revisions

If the first version isn’t right, there’s a Request a Redo button directly under the lyrics. When you press it, you can describe what you’d like changed, even if that’s a different feel for the whole song, a detail that didn’t land, or a specific line you’d rather lose, and the next version is built around those notes rather than starting from scratch. That makes the redo useful for small fixes as well as big ones. The site says revisions are included until you’re happy with the result, and the unlimited-redo option at checkout is the one to pick if you expect to iterate.

GiftMusic customer support

Support is handled by email and a contact form, and the site says it’s available around the clock. We sent a question about how the vocals are produced and whether the recipient needs an account to listen.

Is GiftMusic worth it? Who it suits, and the alternatives

GiftMusic is for anyone who wishes to give a personal present but shouldn’t have to wait long for that occasion. Sending it soon means it’s actually feasible to send it out on the very same day as a birthday, and since the questionnaire is straightforward enough for a parent or grandparent to fill out by themselves, it’s highly surface-level. The shipment time is very quick, which is great when it’s a same-day birthday, which most custom songs don’t supply, and it is straightforward sufficient for a parent or grandparent to fill out unaided. The 14 genres also make it easier to make sure that the song will better suit the recipient’s taste rather than going with a generic ballad.

Songfinch and Songlorious are the two most popular alternatives when you’d like a name artist to write and record the song. Both involve a single artist choosing a piece from his/her collection and are commonly available within days to a week, and are another compromise: more work from a single artist, longer waiting, and (usually) higher prices for that service. GiftMusic’s unique advantage is its speed and wide range of music genres, in addition to the minimal effort required for orders. Out of the three, this is one that can fit the deadline of tonight!

GiftMusic review

GiftMusic delivered just what it promised and even a little more, and a little quicker. The questionnaire will take several minutes, the song will take several minutes, and the lyrics will take several minutes, as they will be created based on the information provided and not copied. The cinematic finish is high enough to be played at a party without the worry of embarrassment, and the shareable page allows it to be handed out easily.

Knowing the rules and providing detailed answers, using the redo notes if there is a line or a detail that needs adjusting, are limitations and are easy to plan around. Personal, fast, and just a little unexpected, it does the trick for a personal gift. 4.8 out of 5.