Phish played The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon tonight while in New York City after playing their three-night run at Randall’s Island. The band delivered a version of “Waiting All Night” for the studio audience and also taped a version of “Fuego” for the web. No word on whether or not NBC executives were in charge of what Fishman had to wear on stage, but he looks noticeably weirder than usual considering he’s not in his signature attire.

Check out the videos below.